I’m back!!! After a much longer break than I intended, I finally have new content to share. School starting back up combined with my writer’s block kept me away, but I will try and post more often from now on. Anyway, I’ve heard rumors from multiple sources that Ariana Grande is being seriously considered for the role of Elphaba in the Wicked movie adaptation, originally set for release sometime next year. Before I start sharing my thoughts, I would like to acknowledge that yes, I do know that Ari has Broadway training and was in the musical 13 as a teenager. I’ve done my research.
That being said, I just don’t think Elphie is a role she’s fit for. I’m not completely against the idea of her being on Broadway or even in the movie (Nessarose, possibly), but this part is one that someone else should fill the shoes of. The only advantage to having her in it would be mainstream buzz from the non-Broadway crowd, but that could be done if she were in any role. (Again, Nessarose.) Here is a list of underappreciated and talented Broadway actresses who should be casted instead:
- Hailey Kilgore, known for the revival of Once on This Island, would be a great fit.
- Talia Suskauer, who recently took on Elphaba in the National Tour.
- Jessica Vosk, another past Elphaba who was a total fan favorite.
- Ariana DeBose, whose credits include Hamilton (OBC) and A Bronx Tale (OBC)
- Maggie McKenna, who recently finished the tour of Dear Evan Hansen as Zoe Murphy and was phenomenal. She’s also a relatively fresh face.
- Laura Michelle Kelly, a personal favorite of mine for Finding Neverland.
- Fantasy: Eva Noblezada, even though she says she’ll never leave Hadestown.
- Jasmine Cephas Jones, original Maria Reynolds in Hamilton.
- Mandy Gonzalez of In the Heights
- Ashley Park, known for originating Gretchen in Mean Girls.
- Kiersey Clemons, Joanne in Rent Live!
And I’m sure I’ll think of more after I publish this. Also for the role of Glinda some Hollywood talent that could still sing the role includes Anna Kendrick or Amanda Seyfried. Other Broadway actresses I would cast as Glinda are Betsy Wolfe, Laura Osnes, and Kara Lindsay (again.) Casting directors, hear my prayer: give Broadway actresses the attention they deserve!!!
Who would you cast in these two leading ladies’ roles? Let me know in the comments 🙂